Defending Dissent: How Campaign Legal Center Is Protecting the First Amendment

Image
People hold up a sign in front of the U.S. Capitol building that reads "We the People WILL BE HEARD"
A demonstration at U.S. Capitol Building in Washington, D.C. Photo by Dennis MacDonald / Alamy Stock Photo

Key takeaways:

  • The Trump administration is using its authority to punish critics, silence opposing views and retaliate against those who challenge them. These actions violate Americans’ First Amendment rights.    
  • Campaign Legal Center defends the First Amendment by challenging unconstitutional government retaliation against political dissent and protecting the rights of people to speak, protest and participate in democracy without fear of political intimidation.
  • Campaign Legal Center and its affiliate Campaign Legal Center Action are fighting to stop ICE from retaliating against constitutional observers, defend the right to free speech by elected officials, end President Donald Trump’s corrupt scheme giving paying Truth Social subscribers early access to presidential announcements and more. 

 

The First Amendment guarantees Americans the freedom to speak out, protest government actions and hold those in power accountable. But the Trump administration and its allies have increasingly been using their authority to punish critics, silence opposing views and retaliate against those who challenge them. This not only threatens the rights of those impacted by these policies, but it also impacts all Americans by creating a chilling effect for those who would speak out.  

↩ Go back to Season 6 episodes

Click "Subscribe" to listen on your podcast platform of choice. ⬆        

Campaign Legal Center (CLC) defends the First Amendment — at the state and federal levels — by challenging unconstitutional government retaliation against political dissent and protecting the rights of people to speak, protest and participate in democracy without fear of political intimidation.  

Protecting Americans from Abuses by Federal Law Enforcement  

In cities across the country, Americans have organized networks of constitutional observers to exercise their First Amendment rights and hold federal agents accountable as those agents carry out an aggressive and brutal deportation campaign. 

In response, multiple federal agencies, including Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), have abused their power by intimidating and retaliating against Americans who lawfully observe federal agents conducting their official duties in public. That retaliation violates the First Amendment.   

CLC filed a lawsuit in federal court on behalf of a constitutional observer, Michael Khalili, and the nonprofit organization Common Cause challenging First Amendment violations by several federal agencies, including ICE, and their leaders.   

The lawsuit alleges that ICE and other federal agencies — pursuant to directives from senior agency officials — are engaged in a nationwide policy of violating the First Amendment by targeting individuals who lawfully observe, photograph and record federal immigration agents performing their official duties in public. 

In addition to our lawsuit against ICE and other federal agencies, Campaign Legal Center worked with the Institute for Constitutional Advocacy and Protection (ICAP) to submit an amicus brief in a separate case, Tincher v. Noem. In that case, we represented over three dozen former career civil servants in the U.S. Department of Justice’s Civil Rights Division calling on the courts to hold federal law enforcement agents accountable for First Amendment violations. 

The Tincher brief supported six plaintiffs in Minnesota — suing on behalf of all constitutional observers and protestors in the Twin Cities — who claimed their constitutional rights were violated when ICE and other federal agents retaliated against them for peacefully observing and recording law enforcement activity. 

In the leadup to the 2026 midterms, the federal government embarked on an intimidation and coercion campaign that impacted both voters and election workers. The Department of Homeland Security launched a harmful voter investigation program, and the federal government threatened to prosecute election officials. Two different cases were filed challenging these actions. 

CLC submitted amicus briefs on behalf of Justice Connection in California Nurses Association v. Mullin and SEIU v. DOJ. Our briefs highlighted that the federal government has historically played a crucial role in preventing voter intimidation, but ahead of the 2026 midterms was engaging in activities that instead perpetrated it. Our briefs explained that the government was not adhering to its own longstanding internal guidelines designed to prevent intimidation and prevent the federal government from intimidating or coercing election officials or intimidating voters ahead of Election Day. 

Defending Against Political Retaliation 

The First Amendment guarantees Americans the freedom to speak out, protest government actions and hold those in power accountable. But the Trump administration and its allies have increasingly been using their authority to punish critics, silence opposing views and retaliate against those who challenge them. This not only threatens the rights of those impacted by these policies, but it also impacts all Americans by creating a chilling effect for those who would speak out.  

Retaliation against its perceived enemies has been a defining feature of the Trump administration. Campaign Legal Center filed an amicus brief opposing efforts to punish law firms for representing clients and causes disfavored by the administration, protecting the freedom to advocate and seek legal representation. 

Politically motivated firings have become a key tool for political retaliation. Dozens of career FBI agents were fired for investigating efforts to interfere with the certification of results in the 2020 presidential election. In response, Campaign Legal Center filed a brief in support of the agents’ cases challenging their firings, emphasizing the importance of First Amendment protections for nonpartisan law enforcement officials.  

Veteran federal prosecutor Maurene Comey was also fired in an act of politically motivated retaliation against her father, former FBI Director James Comey, an outspoken critic of the Trump administration. CLC filed an amicus brief pushing back against this firing and arguing that political retaliation is an existential threat to the rule of law.  

As CLC argued in our brief filed on behalf of Michael Feinberg and Justice Connection — a coalition of former DOJ employees concerned with Trump’s weaponization of government and threats to the rule of law — the courts can and should prevent extreme abuses of presidential power that threaten First Amendment rights.   

The court sided with us in late October, ruling that Comey’s firing was unlawful and ordering that she be reinstated to her job with back pay.  

Safeguarding Equal Access to Government Information 

CLC filed an amicus brief challenging a scheme that gives paying Truth Social subscribers early access to official presidential announcements, arguing that preferential access to government communications undermines First Amendment protections for the press and public while opening the door to corruption and self-dealing. 

Protecting the Nonpartisan Civil Service 

CLC filed a brief challenging executive actions that create a new employment category that reclassified certain “policy-influencing” government employees and stripped them of key procedural protections. In our brief, we explain that these executive actions are subject to judicial review, undermine congressional intent and threaten to chill the speech of federal employees. 

CLC also took action to prevent compelled partisan speech in government emails. We filed a brief protecting federal employees from being forced to deliver partisan political messages through their government email accounts without their consent. Last year, the court sided with our arguments and put an end to this unconstitutional policy. 

Protecting Individuals Who Speak Out 

Just as the Trump administration has retaliated against individuals it views to have political opinions unfavorable to the president, the administration has escalated its effort targeting its perceived enemies by threatening their citizenship.  

In 2025, the federal government quietly expanded a policy that allowed changes to individuals’ visa statuses based on social media posts that the government disagrees with. In response, American Oversight and CLC filed a lawsuit on behalf of CLC to seek more information and transparency about this expanded program.  

In addition to changing visa statuses of those the government disagrees with, the Trump administration has also weaponized its investigatory powers to target perceived political opponents like Rep. Ilhan Omar, whom the administration has threatened to strip of citizenship. CLC published an analysis explaining the legal framework governing denaturalization, tracing the historical use of denaturalization from the 19th century to today, outlining the constitutional provisions that constrain its use and identifying concerning trends in denaturalization cases, including the current administration’s use of denaturalization to target political opponents like Rep. Omar. 

In addition to federal threats to political dissent and the First Amendment, threats have materialized at the state level.  

In May 2026, Tennessee Governor Bill Lee called a special legislative session to gerrymander Tennessee’s congressional map in the wake of the U.S. Supreme Court’s Callais v. Louisiana decision. The aim was to redraw the map to crack the predominantly Black city of Memphis into three congressional districts. 

At the special session, Senator Charlane Oliver denounced the new map as a blatant attempt to disenfranchise Black voters in Tennessee.  

Senate Speaker Randy McNally and Chief Clerk Russell Humphrey retaliated against Senator Oliver due to her speech, in blatant violation of Senator Oliver’s constitutional rights. Legislative leadership refused to count Senator Oliver’s vote against Tennessee’s new gerrymandered congressional map, and they imposed a series of punishments that substantially interfere with Senator Oliver’s ability to represent her more than 200,000 constituents.  

ICAP and Campaign Legal Center Action filed a lawsuit on behalf of Tennessee state Senator Charlane Oliver and her constituents, challenging unlawful retaliation by the Tennessee Senate’s leadership.    

Why is protecting the First Amendment important? 

The right to political participation, to dissent, to a free exchange of ideas are the bedrock of any democracy. The First Amendment protects all of us, but those protections only endure when they are defended. 

Campaign Legal Center’s First Amendment work is rooted in the simple principle that government officials may not use their power to silence critics, punish dissent, compel political speech or reward allies at the expense of constitutional freedoms. Your support helps us hold government officials accountable when they threaten the constitutional rights that make our democracy possible, including the right to dissent. 

Madeleine is a Communications Associate at CLC.
American flag
We are protecting the rule of law.